Humphreys Half Moon Inn offers a resort-style experience on Shelter Island with a strong 4.5/5 rating from over 2,800 reviews. Guests consistently praise the peaceful waterfront location, beautiful tropical grounds, and Hawaiian ambiance. The property is particularly notable for its concert venue and entertainment offerings. While most guests enjoy the clean rooms and helpful staff members like Darleen, some note additional fees and occasional inconsistent restaurant service. The location provides easy access to local dining and marina activities, making it a popular choice for both entertainment-focused stays and relaxing getaways.